The Spinner Rack is the Daily Miltonian’s extremely infrequent but always satisfying review feature about individual issues of comic books. This post-Turkey-wrapup-edition was written by our good pal Brady Dale. This is Brady:

Brady was going to write about some sort of indie obscure scratchy art zine comic something-or-other but here’s an important fact: Brady can’t get enough of Marvel Comics heavy-as-lead mega summer-into-winter cross-over extravaganza Civil War. Did we mention Brady also loves the Punisher? Oh because he so does. Then Brady went to his local comic store and oh shit will you look at this! There’s a new Punisher series. And you know what else? It’s a Civil War crossover! So Brady, not being able to stop himself (and can you blame him?), decided to write about said issue. And you, you lucky bastard you, get to read it. To wit:
“Dance With the Girl that Brung Ya” - A Spinner Rack Review
Punisher War Journal, vol. 2, #1
Writer: Matt Fraction
Artist: Ariel Olivetti
Marvel, $2.99

When Garth Ennis brought back the Punisher a few years ago in the
groundbreakingly sadistic mini-series, “Welcome Back, Frank,” he
imagined Frank Castle as a superhero that couldn’t stand other
super-heroes. Ennis has had a hell of a run with the Punisher and, I
suspect, a hell of a lot of fun. As it went on, I would get so excited
about new Punisher work that sometimes it felt like he was my new
favorite character. Or maybe Ennis is just my favorite comics writer.
That’s why I met the news that a new Punisher title was coming out with
considerable skepticism. How much would I enjoy another title if Ennis’s
was not the sick and twisted mind devising new ways for the Punisher to
increase his unbelievable body count? Fortunately for me, Marvel pulled
their current trump card on me. The blacked out the bottom half the
cover and stuck two words in that blackness that I now notice they’ve
had the audacity to trademark: “Civil War.”
That’s right, Punisher War Zone is a Civil War crossover. Currently,
there are only two circumstances under which I buy a floppy comic book
these days: it either has the number ‘52′ real big up at the top, or it
has that crazy half-blacked out cover that indicates its a Civil War
tie-in.
When I heard about this issue I thought, well, here’s a quandary:
Ennis’s Punisher is almost superhero-free. You can’t have a Civil War
tie-in without lots and lots of superheroes. So how far from outside
Ennis vision I so enjoy would Punisher War Journal fall?
In the Ennis world of the Punisher, other superheroes only show up so
the Punisher can humiliate them. He doesn’t humiliate them by beating
them up, either. No, no. That would be pedestrian to the charmingly
twisted mind of Garth Ennis. His Punisher tends to acknowlege the other
heroes definitely could beat the crap out of him, if they were ever
given a shot at a fair fight. The Punisher never lets them have that
shot, though. He always finds some way to prevent them from ever getting
close, usually using their own moral limitations against them in some
manner that makes a larger point about how useless their crusades are
when they aren’t willing to kill killers.
Anyway, not to digress into ethical pondering about whether or not the
Punisher’s methods are right or wrong, the larger point is that Matt
Fraction is picking up where Ennis has left off. He has no choice but to
pick up there. See, the Punisher had been a revolutionary character, the
first major anti-hero. As such, he became one of the hottest tickets in
the Marvel line, but then somehow he lost his charm in the 90s and they
killed Frank Castle off. For years, no one cared. In fact, I remember
just sort of not picking up the Punisher in the middle of some story arc
and always vaguely wondering how it had ended.
And why I never noticed Punisher on the spinner racks anymore?
Then, Ennis brought him back from the dead. Both literally and in the
public imagination. He did such a good job that they went ahead and made
a Punisher movie that borrowed heavily from the first Ennis mini-series.
So what’s Fraction end up doing with what Ennis left him with? As it
turns out, great things.
He’s no Ennis, but that’s fine. He’s still good. Fraction gives us a
Punisher that’s a normal guy. A normal guy who happens to be able to
beat ten trained men to the ground and knows how to fire heavy tank guns
while under fire. A normal guy with Black Ops training. A normal guy
stuck in a world over-populated with costumed clowns, some of whom are
murdering lunatics and all of whom get in the way of his one man war on
violent criminals. They all annoy the Punisher.
He tells the story of how the Punisher gets sucked into the current
costume on costume Civil War that the big crossover is named for. Along
the way, the Punisher has to slowly wade deeper and deeper into the
world of superheroes, super-tech and super-mentality. He is amusingly
disdainful of it all the whole way. He delights in watching Stilt-Man
get ripped from his stilt legs and fall to the ground as his old armored
appendages writhe. He calls the tracking device a mad scientist loans
him a ‘doohickey.’ He refers to a rifle he lifts off of disabled
S.H.I.E.L.D. agents a “government space-gun.” When he almost dies at one
point in the issue, it isn’t death itself that scares him but
death-by-cutesy-robot.
You also have to love the characterization of the Punisher’s foil in the
story, Commander Bridge. Bridge is a tough old bird from the same school
as Frank Castle: the old school. They don’t see each other, but they
each know who they’re fighting. They respect each other. They’d rather
not be on opposite sides. Bridge is the sort of guy who jokes about
flooding New York’s storm drain system with liquid fire and stands
around drinking coffee and reading the paper while ordering
twenty-somethings into a tunnel after the nation’s most notorious
killing machine.
Bridge gives voice to the reason why such a flagrant law-breaker as the
Punisher goes free in New York City, despite all the security there (if
you read the main series, you already know the answer: cops like him).
When he decides that principle will force him to resign in order to
better do the work he’s been assigned to do, he doesn’t do it without
worrying a bit about losing his pension. After all, Bridge is an old
guy. He’s got a paunch. He wants to quit doing this stuff someday.
The only thing noticeably absent from Punisher War Journal is, well, the
War Journal. Once upon a time, the Punisher’s thoughts and narrations
were narrated as entries into his “War Journal.” He did this for years.
“Punisher War Journal entry #XY993256″ - just fragged the fucking
Ringmaster. Finished his pizza and came home.” That sort of thing. No
mention of the war journal in War Journal #1. Perhaps no one remembers
that that is where they got the title for Punisher’s second book from,
back in the day, or maybe no one cares. I don’t really care, I just
think its funny.
I also think it’s funny that Fraction brings back a version of Microchip
(Castle’s old tech backup), because I know that as soon as Ennis reads
that he’s going to come up with an excuse to kill the new Microchip,
too, over in the main title. Wouldn’t it be funny of Ennis and Fraction
got into their own little one character civil war over the Frank Castle
myth?
Anyway, as for the first issue, I’ve read it a few times now and I just
bought it at noon today. In case this wasn’t all that obvious yet, I’ll
make it simple for you: I liked it. I like Fraction’s blue collar
Punisher. If I had any criticism of the Ennis Punisher, it’s that
Ennis’s is a little snooty. Fraction’s Punisher is a guy you could have
a beer with.
I also have to give a nod to the broader Marvel editorial regime. This
month, a lot of different books are intermingling with each other.
Punisher War Journal is mixed up in Civil War #5 and Amazing Spider Man
#536. It’s all managed artfully and elegantly. This is a neater, more
tightly packed crossover event than I have ever seen a comic book
company manage (though I have also been out of the scene a little while).
Fraction has kicked off his new book with all the indications of a good
run to come. The next issue’s title is promising: “How I Won the War:
Pt. 1 - Bring on the Bad Guys.” Yes, please do bring them on. We have
seen little of Marvel’s super-villainry since the Civil War started, and
you’d think there are all sorts of advantages they could take amidst
hero-on-hero chaos like this. Who better to answer the question of where
the bad guys have gone than the anti-hero so good at sending evil-do’ers
to their final destination?
Let’s just hope that Fraction’s work is good enough that when they quit
putting these Civil War banners on the bottom half of comic covers that
they he still draws a big enough crowd that Marvel take his books into
trade paperback reprint, because that’s the format I take the rest of my
comics in these days.
Punisher War Journal, vol. 2 - his stats so far: 4 guns, 5 body bags, 1
good issue.
Any of you freaks got a Spinner Rack to submit — any comic, any era, any issue — just mainline that shit straight into our veins via info@truejersey.com and it’ll be up on here faster than Fishtown casinos. Oof.